Concrete vs. Fiberglass vs. Vinyl: An Honest Comparison

It’s time to make an honest comparison between concrete vs. fiberglass vs. vinyl pools. Each one has its advantages and challenges. But which pool is best for your Tennessee backyard and lifestyle? Should you choose concrete, fiberglass, or vinyl? Here’s what you need to know.

Comparing Vinyl Pools

Out of all the pools types, vinyl pools are one of the most affordable upfront. They have a smooth surface, so they are resistant to algae, making them easy to maintain.

However, while they have some design and style choices, vinyl liner pools don’t quite have the same level of customization that other types of pools provide. You’re really only limited to shape, pattern, and color options on the liner itself.

Vinyl pools also have the shortest life expectancy compared to fiberglass and concrete. With proper care, they can last from 6 to 10 years, but they just aren’t as durable and will eventually need to be replaced.

Comparing Fiberglass

Fiberglass pools do have a lot of advantages, like less maintenance and upkeep. Like vinyl, they have a smooth surface, which makes them resistant to algae growth. Steps and seats can be part of the pool design and they are quick to install.

There are some challenges with fiberglass, though. Molds are used to create them so you are limited to only the model, size, and color choices offered. Fiberglass pools must be shipped to your backyard, which means the added cost for shipping. This also means the pool cannot be wider than 16 feet so it can be delivered by truck, so again, the sizing is limited. Another issue is that it may get damaged during shipment and any repairs done may not match the original finish.

Comparing Concrete Pools

When it comes to designs with concrete pools, the options are endless.

When it comes to longevity and durability, a concrete pool is your best bet. With proper care and maintenance, a concrete pool can last for decades. And when it comes to designs, the customization options are endless. You can choose any shape or style, and customize your pool with tanning ledges, water and fire features, and more, making concrete pools a solid investment. Especially if you’re looking for a luxury pool.

The only limitation you have to keep in mind is the size of your backyard, but this applies to any pool, including concrete pools. However, this is another perk to a concrete pool, because it can be custom sized for your backyard, whether it’s big or small.

A potential downside is the length of installation time. While most pool builds hit snags along the way, a concrete pool build can have a variety of interruptions, including permitting and subcontracting delays. Along with the normal amount of time it takes, these snags can stretch a concrete pool build into several months.

An Honest Comparison of Concrete vs. Fiberglass vs. Vinyl Pool

Comparing concrete vs. fiberglass vs. vinyl, the advantages of a concrete pool are obvious. You have more customization options like size, shape, and features. A concrete pool is durable and long-lasting and will give you years of fun with family and friends. 

Plus unlike other concrete pools, with Bellareed Luxury Pools you even have the advantage of a smooth concrete pool installation. All work is done in-house, from design to permitting to construction. So no delays from the permit application and no hangups from subcontractors. We’ve streamlined the pool construction process so you can have your custom luxury concrete pool in 12 weeks. Schedule a free design consultation with our team at Bellareed today.